Google Podcasts is dead – as is my trust in the survival of any Google service
With the death of Google Podcasts, space must be in short supply over at Google Graveyard
Google killed another product last week. “It must be Tuesday,” I quipped, on hearing the news. And, pleasingly, it actually was Tuesday when this particular product was shuttered. Amazing! Sometimes, everything just falls into place. Unless you were a fan of Google Podcasts, because Google Podcasts is now dead.
Google Podcasts (2018–2024) follows Google Listen (2009–2012) and Google Play Music (2011–2020) into oblivion. And if you think a trio of podcast players (yes, I’m counting Google Play Music) being killed by one company across a mere 15 years is a problem, you’re absolutely right. But then that’s Google. It has form in this area – and no sense of focus.
The Google lifecycle appears to be that someone gets excited about a shiny new idea, hurls a product into the market, and then stumbles into another Google offering doing much the same thing. Then the Google Borg tires of the once new and shiny thing when it’s old, tarnished and superfluous. Finally, presuming everyone has less memory than a ZX81, Google repeats the pattern, promising this time things will be different.
Death is not the end
Only they won’t be. They never are. If you’ve been around the tech block a few times, you’ll be very aware Google is the scorpion and you are the frog. Or perhaps Google is dozens of scorpions, all fighting each other for the reward of pricking you. Either way, you end up getting stung more times than is entirely reasonable.
My first brush with the Google lifecycle was Google Reader (2005–2013). I loved Google Reader. It was the perfect way to follow online sources. And then Google killed it. Eight years’ service meant nothing when Reader wasn’t bringing in cold, hard cash. And in Reader’s wake, there wasn’t even a replacement – just a gaping hole where it used to be. The lesson? Don’t get too attached and don’t rely on anything Google makes.
So I played it cool with Google Buzz (2010–2011), Google+ (2011–2019) and Google Hangouts (2013–2022), when certain friends in tech raved about each in turn, convinced it would be the next big thing. I looked on suspiciously at Google Stadia (2019–2023), reasoning Microsoft cared about gaming, whereas Google would nonchalantly toss its efforts aside, like a broken old Commodore 64. As for Google Play Music (2011–2020), just for the music rather than podcasts? No thanks. For me, it was Spotify and Apple Music all the way.
Shake it up
But all this is maddening for another reason: Google has the potential for brilliance. In the podcasts space alone, Google could have unleashed disruption and innovation like no-one else, combining its skills in infrastructure, discovery, information provision and app design. Instead, Google Podcasts is dead and trust in the longevity of Google services is further eroded.
So what’s next? At least with podcasts, there are alternatives for listing to your favourite shows. But probably avoid Google’s suggestion: YouTube. It wants you listening to podcasts in YouTube Music or even watching them on YouTube itself – because podcasts are known for visual spectacle, and YouTube for mobile’s lack of background playback unless you subscribe is a much-loved feature.
And what happens when Google gets bored of even these things – and others? Eventually, it’ll be just you and the YouTube Borg. A monolithic tech stew of video, music and podcasts. Email and messaging replaced by comment threads. Docs turned into AI videos helmed by Google robots.
Meanwhile, Elon Musk will look on, fuming that Google cobbled together his hallowed ‘everything’ app entirely by accident. But he needn’t worry: chances are Google will shut it all down in a few months anyway.
Craig Grannell
Contributor